“How shall we sing God’s song in a foreign
land? How shall we sing God’s song on alien soil? As people of faith we wrestle
with this question as we attempt to be faithful witnesses in the midst of the
issues of our day, the issues that often make us feel and live as though we are
in a strange land.
A
land that is hostile and forbidding. A land that is deadly. A land in which the
prejudices of a few can become the law of the land, a land in which the dignity
of all persons has conditions put on it so that some of us need not apply for
justice or mercy.
How
is it in this strange land you and I are called to sing God’s song in the midst
of the world’s evils and hatreds and prejudices and violence? Can we sing this
song by becoming disillusioned and cynical? Can we sing this song by engaging
in ritualistic dances? Can we sing this song by escaping into a simple place in
time by seeking easy answers?
You have to know where you want to be, you
have to live your life standing on the promises, you must live in a radical
hope that never excepts someone else’s definition of wholeness particularly if
they are the only ones benefitting from it. She believed that you live your
story and sing your song and remain steadfast in your faith and preach your
witness and God will take care of the rest.”
Rev. Dr. Emilie Townes
Over the weekend, I read an article in The New York
Times, From the Streets to the ‘World’s
Best Mom,’ on the subject of sex trafficking. The woman whom the article
was written about is in recovery from drug abuse and prostitution and she lives
here in Nashville. The article begins with the woman that is being interviewed
referencing that her mother, who was an addict, had taught her about oral sex
when she was six years old. The woman being interviewed said she ran away from
home at age fourteen and this was when she started working as a prostitute for
a pimp. She said, “that she would be dead by now if it weren’t for a remarkable
initiative by the Rev. Becca Stevens, the Episcopal priest at Vanderbilt
University here, to help women escape trafficking and prostitution.” Rev.
Stevens founded a residential rehabilitation program for women, Magdalene and
Thistle Farms, that were or are suffering from drug abuse and have a history of
prostitution. The article goes on to say, “Rev. Stevens herself had been abused
as a girl — by a family friend in her church, beginning when she was 6 years
old — and she shared with so many trafficked women the feelings of vulnerability,
injustice and anger that go with having been molested.” “Sex trafficking is one of the most severe
human rights violations in America today. In some cases, it amounts to a modern
form of slavery. One reason we as a society don’t try harder to uproot it is
that it seems hopeless.”
In plenty good
room, Marcia Y. Riggs explores sexual-gender ethics. She analyzes the
stories of men and women as gender social groups within the church as a community
or social institution.(10) Riggs states, “It is my contention, however, that
when African American women and men are in complicity with sexual-gender
injustice in the church, the church betrays its moral vision and corrupts both
its internal moral life and its witness in the larger society.”(97) Within the collection of writings, Riggs
introduces the case of Anita Hill and Clearance Thomas. She explains how it is “a
significant, public example of how African American sexual-gender relations can
do the social reproductive work of sustaining white
racist-patriarchal-capitalism while perpetrating sexual-gender oppressive ideas
within the African American community is the case of Anita Hill and Clarence
Thomas.”(54) Riggs cited examples of words and phrases that Thomas used in his
case against Hill that brought the focus back to race instead of the sexual harassment,
that he was being accused of. “Here was the crux of the matter for African
Americans: A black woman betrayed the race by publicly accusing a black man of
sexual impropriety. In a white racist society, even if Thomas had done what
Hill said, Hill should not have spoken of it in mixed racial company.” (59)
If Hill were to have remained silent about her
experience with Thomas then her silence would have condoned the potential
injustice that had been acted upon her. Where then, is a safe and appropriate
place for African American women to tell their stories, use voices of integrity
without feeling like they are contributing to white oppression? So, not only
are African American women being socially oppressed by white people but then
they are also oppressed with the pressure to be silent so as to protect their
race from further scrutiny.
Going back to plenty
good room, Riggs concludes that, “although there are traditional or
status-quo sexual-gender roles deriving from the sexual gender morality, these
roles can be changed because (1) the roles are learned – historically specific
and relative and (2) persons are moral beings (have the capacity to be
intentional) who can challenge and resist traditional roles and expectations.
Transforming the sexual-gender relations of African American women and men in
the church will thus be accomplished through moral education that effects counter
socialization.”(100)
A ministry that I would like to learn more about is
that of women’s prison ministry. In the article, I referenced at the beginning
of this reflection, from the New York Times, the woman that was interviewed,
having graduated her recovery program is now dedicating some of her time to
prison ministry. In the article, she talks about meeting a teenage prostitute
in prison, who claims, that it was visits from this woman that gave her the
hope and motivation to think about a life outside of prostitution.
Works
Cited:
Rev. Dr. Emilie Townes, Songs of Zion, St Augustine’s Chapel, October 13, 2013.
Nicholas Kristof, “From the Streets to the ‘World’s Best Mom,’” New York Times, October 12, 2013.
Marcia Y. Riggs, plenty
good room, Eugene, Oregon: Wipf and Stock Publishers, 2003.
Lara, I enjoyed that you specifically highlighted the Hill-Thomas hearings in your blog this week. I wanted to focus on them as well, but got a bit side tracked! ;0) You brought out some really key points in the reading. I think that being a woman in church, particularly the Black silence is an expectancy because women are considered the inferior sex who are almost expected to be corrected or handled like children. What were you thoughts about the bell hooks' essays? did you see any correlation between what Riggs talked about and what hooks mentioned? I would have like to get your thought on hooks, but I really have seen you stretching your thinking about race and gender. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteLara, like Nicole I also enjoyed how you used the Hill-Thomas Hearing in your post. For me, I can see the parallels that it has with the number of sexual harassment or assault accusations within the black church that have been placed against clergymen and how in many cases the perception of the female accuser comes into question. What are some of your thoughts on accusations of sexual impropriety from clergymen? Do you believe that there are instances in which the "accuser" is in some part responsible in the accusations being made? I would like to suggest for further study an analysis of cases in which sexual impropriety occurred from the pulpit for the purpose of objectively identifying wether or not the accuser had any responsibility in the outcome resulting in the accusation.
ReplyDeleteLara, I appreciate some of the questions you've brought forth in this post. One that I really enjoyed particularly was: "Where then, is a safe and appropriate place for African American women to tell their stories, use voices of integrity without feeling like they are contributing to white oppression?" This is a question I wish I knew the answer to some days. When I talk about my experiences with other women who have experienced the same thing - it feels good to be understood but it still does nothing for the places where these oppressive experiences still reside and exist. Do you think that this lack of safety is what leads to young women and girls not speaking up about sexual abuse you spoke about in the beginning of your blog? And, is this lack of safety something that would cause you to remain complicit or silent in the face of oppression within your own faith community? I think an interesting study involving women's prison ministry would be to assess how much sexual-gender oppression these women faced before incarceration and during incarceration. It would be interesting to observe how a sexist-patriarchal social construct is at work within institutions such as prison in comparison to religious institutions.
ReplyDeleteThanks for your post, Lara. I enjoyed the way you wove the story of the woman from Magdalene into Riggs's reflections. As we've talked about, the work of Magdalene is such good work, and the fact that Rev. Stevens is a female minister who was abused *in church* is all the more related, and part of the reason she does her work today. Well done! What do you think the moral education toward resocialization along sexual-gender justice lines in churches and in society might look like? Would you possibly take any clues from Magdalene and Thistle Farms? What sort of steps and actions would allow for such a re-education in our churches (and in society)? As for prison ministry or interaction with women in prisons, make sure you talk to Alex Chambers in our class--she's done a lot in the women's jail and prison and does much of her scholarly work on the issues of women's incarceration. Perhaps some reflection on the relationship between churches, prison ministry, and incarcerated women would be something to think further on? Especially what sorts of sexual-gender roles more traditional prison ministries might bring out to women's prisons. Thanks for your reflections!
ReplyDelete