On Sunday morning, I arrived and
walked into the Chapel just in time for the processional hymn to begin. My
messenger bag made a loud thump on the wooden pew as I hurried to settle in; I
had planned to go to the library following the service. I secured my coffee
mug, that I had snuck in, in the corner at the end of the pew and picked up my
bulletin and began to sing along. I noticed as the Priests slowly made their
way down the aisle of the church, that there was a guest priest walking along
side of the Chaplin and associate Priest. I concluded just by watching the
guest, that he was beaming with joy and his face was lit up, he seemed very loving,
approachable, he carried himself with an abundance of peace and selflessness.
Once the procession arrived at the altar, I noticed that he was dressed
different than the other two priests and wondered what occasion would have him
wear the puffy white blouse and brightly colored vest. This guest was Bishop
Curry, he is an African American Episcopal Bishop from the diocese of North
Carolina, he had been invited by the chapel to come meet the community and
preach.
The
Bishop was given the difficult task of preaching a sermon on the scripture
found in the book of Luke 16: 1-13, The Parable of the Dishonest Manager. The
focus of his sermon was that God is in the business of “taking a mess and making a miracle.” When the Bishop
summarized the parable, he compared the rich man and manager in the story to
the white slave owner and African American slave in our country’s history. The
manager in Luke’s parable would have been considered a slave to the rich man
within that culture and time. He talked about the socio economic atmosphere of
our country during the time of slavery. How the rich continued to get richer
and the poor continued to get poorer. The Bishop compared the debt of the
manager and the rich man’s debtors to the inescapable debts that permeated the
African American race. He explained, that Jesus’ commending of the manager for
redistributing the debts owed by his debtors in the favor of the manager was an
exaltation and Jesus praised him for his
creativity. The rich man’s manager had figured out a way to be liberated of his
debt. “God will liberate the weak from the injustice of the strong.” (27)
“When Israel was in
Egypt’ land,
Let my people go;
Oppressed so hard
they could not stand,
Let my people go;
Go down Moses, ‘way
down in Egypt’s land.
Tell ole Pharaoh
Let my people go.”
Some of these Old Testament
stories of people bound in slavery in Egypt are some of the first stories that
the African American slaves learned about in America and these stories acted as
seeds of new beginnings of the black Christian faith. (44,Paris) The manager
from Luke’s parable had taken the mess that he was in and made a miracle. Bishop
Curry also made reference to the tales of Br’er Rabbit. James H. Cone wrote
that, “the tales of Br’er Rabbit and his triumphs over the stronger animals
actually expressed black slaves’ conscious hopes and dreams of overcoming the
slave masters themselves.” (56)
In the book, “God of the Oppressed,” the author,
James H. Cone paints the pages with descriptions and a contrasting of ways that
black and white people think about God. (14) The thesis for his book states,
"that one’s social and historical context decides not only the questions
we address to God but also the mode or form of the answers given to the
questions.” (14) Through his writing he describes how he is met with much opposition
from white and black theologians. Cone introduces us to black theology and the
liberation that came from the relationship and devotion by the African American
to the heart of black theology, Jesus Christ. He walks us through some core
characteristics of the black church; black prayer, humor, the Blues, spirituals
and gospel songs, preaching, listening and emotionality.
One of the arguments against black
theology that sought to undermine its central claim was that, “if God is
liberating blacks from oppression, why then are they still oppressed?” I believe
this question leads us into the heart of the metaethical problem. Cone answers
this question by saying, “there is no answer to the problem of theodicy! Faith
is born out of suffering, and suffering is faith’s most powerful contradiction.
This is the Christian dilemma. The only meaningful Christian response is to
resist unjust suffering and to accept the painful consequence of that
resistance.”(x) I believe that the dichotomy that theodicy produces to be
fascinating. If faith to some degree with certain people is produced through
struggle and suffering then “we” must put the time in to explore the sources of
people’s suffering. Cone articulates that with Jesus at the heart of black
theology, we must ask, “What has Africa to do with Jerusalem, and what
difference does Jesus make for African people oppressed in North American? “
(15) Jesus and the resurrection are the ultimate symbols of hope. Life’s
hardships produce the desire and necessity for faith, while the resurrections
that black Christians experience and identify each day, give them the strength
to persevere and the steadfast hope to know that Jesus Christ is here among us.
As I sat with a priest one morning,
I brought up the problem of theodicy. She thoughtfully responded that she did
not have the answer to our world’s great travesties and sufferings but that she
would share with me a story from a book she was reading. She was reading the
biography of a holocaust victim. The victim depicted life within a Jewish
concentration camp. There was one particularly devastating moment in the book
where the writer is witnessing the torture of a child, the child was being hung
and the community of people were made to watch the treacherous event. My priest
said that the man in the story with a sorrow that is incomprehensible and
hopelessness that penetrates down to the bone, leaned over to the woman next to
him and said, “where can God be in this place.” The woman responded, “God is
there on the platform, God is with the child.”
Going forward, I would love to
spend time in a third world country learning about Christian theology through
the immersion of a different culture and inter relational experience.
Specifically I am interested in researching Christian theology in South America,
Latin American Theology. I would like to learn about the development of and
sustainability of faith in the context of people living in very urban
environments and indigenous people living in the most rural villages in South
America.
Works Cited:
Cone, James H. God of
the Oppressed. Orbis Books, 1997.
Paris, Peter J. The
Spirituality of African Peoples. Fortress Press, 1995.
Lara, your posts always have a sense of deep thought and reflection, which is refreshing. I have often thought about the question of suffering in a universal sense, and I know that there is not a person alive who will not experience loss or suffering. It is a part of the human condition. What I have questions about in terms of theodicy is the constant suffering of people of color and how it seems that Black people are caught in a perpetual cycle of oppression that never seems to end. As Du Bois stated in his book, to be black is to be a problem and it seems no amount of faith is going to change that.
ReplyDeleteAs I read your example about the holocaust victim, I was touched by the story, but I also reminded me of the African holocaust that took place for hundreds of years in the form of chattel slavery that this country refuses to acknowledge as a form of mass murder or to pay reparations for (something that Jewish holocaust survivors were given). It is a slap in the face of every African American that our ancestors who helped built this country fail to be a part of the collective memory of America, but instead, America has virtually wiped the social evil of slavery from high school history books. Jewish survivors say "Never forget", but Africans are told to "Forget about it and move on." What saddens me is that we live in a world where the value of a human's life is based on skin color. Over a million Africans were slaughtered in Darfur, and America did nothing to help those people. Right here in America, the people of New Orleans were treated like animals during Hurricane Katrina.
How do you feel African Americans should address the problem of theodicy in light of all the things they have gone through as a people. Do you see any parallels in slavery and the holocaust?
I think it is your desire to go abroad is laudable. I think it would be great, and my hope is that you will use that opportunity to do great things in poor communities here as well. Good luck with that endeavor!
Lara, I enjoyed the way you integrated your time in church with the text and the sermon from the guest preacher. Nicely done. I also appreciate your raising the theodicy question, and the way Cone responds. The story the other priest shared is a great one, from Elie Wiesel's 'Night'. The interesting thing about that account is, if I remember correctly, the person responds to the question of where God is, with something like, "He is there, up on the gallows." So it's left up to interpretation whether the person is saying "God is dead" or "God is in that suffering, dying boy." With Cone, I think we can say that God is both 'with' the dying, suffering person, as you say, but also 'is' the dying, suffering, oppressed person (i.e., the black Christ). I'm also interested to hear more about your hopes for visiting communities in Latin America or elsewhere. What do you intend to learn through such visits? Where do you hope to go? What has led you to desire such a trip? (Also, have you thought about applying for an Imagination Grant at VDS?) On that note, have you read any about the "base communities" of Latin America? Leonardo Boff and some others have interesting texts on the development of liberation theology in those contexts.
ReplyDeleteLara, I appreciate the different dimensions you bring to the discussion on liberation theology by infusing your experience at church and recounting some of the tragic events surrounding the holocaust. You included the question in your post stating: "if God is liberating blacks from oppression, why then are they still oppressed?" I admit that I am still working through this question as well. It is not that I've ever wanted to question the veracity of Jesus' saving grace, but I just wonder why so much oppression is still lingering within the Black Church. After Dr. Floyd-Thomas' lecture, I was able to come to a better understanding as to the liberation not being a product of freedom, rather that liberation itself is to be absolutely invested in the struggle toward it. With that being said, where are you as it relates to your post? Where does a Christian woman who is White find herself in a liberation theology? I really would like to hear how someone in your position finds truth or value in the Black Theological experience. I do not know much about liberation theology (as it relates to education), but I have been researching other progenitors of different ethnic backgrounds. Dr. Miguel De La Torre is a Latino/a Liberation Theology and Social Ethics author and educator. In your interest in Latin American theological studies, do you think you would find similarities between Black Liberation and Latino/a Liberation? It is my hope that you would be able to fuse both your new understanding of Black theology and any future knowledge of Latino/a theology so that you could bring others in your cultural environment closer to the reality of the necessity of these different theologies.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteNice post Lara! I appreciate how you used Sunday's sermon to draw parallels with Cone's text. I personally don't find theodicy to be an issue. I believe that theodicy is the one thing that the oppress look forward to in addition to liberation-- punish the people who did me wrong and help me get from under "the man's " thumb. I think the issue arises when a group of people decide that any form oppression is necessary for the building of ones faith. That group places itself in the shoes of God and then attempts to operate as God's emissary. Have you seen any actions similar to the aforementioned in the past from professing Christians? In what ways do you feel a liberation theology play in the face of those sent to "liberate", especially if the oppressed people feel that the liberators are the cause of the oppression?
ReplyDelete